Symmetric Tax Competition under Formula Apportionment
نویسنده
چکیده
This paper compares property taxation to a corporate income tax based on formula apportionment in a model where identical countries compete to attract capital. We find that if countries can pair a residence-based capital tax with a property tax (source tax on capital) the tax equilibrium is efficient. In contrast, the use of a 2-factor FA scheme based on sales and capital combined with a residence-based capital tax leads to an inefficient outcome.
منابع مشابه
Asymmetric Tax Competition with Formula Apportionment
This paper analyzes asymmetric tax competition under formula apportionment. It sets up a model with multinationals where two welfare-maximizing jurisdictions of different size levy source-based corporate taxes and allocate taxes using the formula approach. At the Nash equilibrium, tax rates are too low and public goods quantities are to small. The paper shows that the larger country levies a la...
متن کاملFormula Apportionment vs. Separate Accounting: A Private Information Perspective
In 2002, the European Commission recommended that member countries use formula apportionment procedures to tax multinational companies. This departure from the standard separate accounting (transfer pricing) approach is an attempt to reduce the costs and distortions associated with auditing transfer prices. Unfortunately, apportionment formulas create their own economic distortions and, contrar...
متن کاملTax Enforcement and Tax Havens under Formula Apportionment
In this paper, we consider optimal tax enforcement policy in the presence of pro t shifting towards tax havens. We show that, under separate accounting, tax enforcement levels may be too high due to negative scal externalities. In contrast, under formula apportionment, tax enforcement is likely to be too low due to positive externalities of tax enforcement. Our results challenge recent contrib...
متن کاملCorporate Income Taxation of Multinationals in a General Equilibrium Model
Using a general multi-country equilibrium model with a multinational enterprise, this paper investigates the efficiency properties of separate accounting and formula apportionment. If governments are large, i.e. take into account the effect of their statutory tax rate on the interest rate, and maximize tax revenues, tax rates under separate accounting may be inefficiently high while tax rates u...
متن کاملWolfgang Eggert und Andreas Haufler : Company tax coordination cum tax rate competition
This paper reviews the recent theoretical literature that analyses the European Union’s policy to eliminate preferential corporate tax regimes and the proposal to introduce a consolidated EU tax base with formula apportionment for the taxation of multinational firms. Since neither proposal includes a harmonisation of corporate tax rates, a core issue is how tax competition between member states...
متن کامل